Search Site

Bad Drinking Water May Equate to Bad Engineering

The New Jersey Appellate Division recently reversed a decision dismissing claims against an engineering firm called Remington & Vernick, brought by a South Jersey municipality the borough of Berlin. The case focused on a request by Berlin to have some additional wells installed to provide drinking water to the community. Apparently, Remington & Vernick was commissioned to provide engineering services and related permitting services associated with this venture. When residents complained about the water tasting bad—water which was generated by the wells which were ultimately installed— Berlin filed suit against Remington & Vernick, and others, alleging that the bad water was a result of their poor professional services.

At first, the trial court dismissed the claims against the engineering firm, finding that Berlin did not have adequate expert testimony to support its claim against the firm. However, Remington & Vernick’s victory was short lived; the Appellate Division reversed and reinstated the case. According to the Appellate Division, the engineer provided by the municipality to offer testimony in conjunction with a hydro-geologist, also offered by the municipality to provide expert testimony, was enough to allow the case to go forward and defeat the engineering firm’s dispositive motion.

There are two lessons to be learned from this case. First, it is important in any case where engineering practices are questioned to have adequate expert testimony on your side in order to go forward with the case. The failure to have qualified experts may very well result in a dismissal. The second point is that expert testimony does not necessarily have to be from one expert; it may very well be that several experts will be required to offer adequate testimony by a plaintiff in a professional malpractice case. As long as in the totality, these professionals cover all of the necessary claims in the professional malpractice case, then that approach is acceptable and the case will survive a motion to dismiss.

The Toxic injury Lawyers are a team of attorneys with great experience in toxic torts, such as contaminated drinking water, sickness and property damage caused by mold, and exposure to harmful chemicals; cases for which routinely require experienced experts for litigation. Our firm has worked with highly qualified experts in myriad fields, ranging from geologists to medical professionals, and our attorneys know what expert is best suited for every matter to provide our clients with the strongest case possible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Attorneys
What clients are saying about us
  • "I highly recommend this law firm because they were responsive and sensitive to my needs and won. I chose this firm after having talked to 6 other firms because within minutes of contacting them I was able to speak to Mr. Lieberman himself. Mr. Lieberman and the junior attorneys did not make me feel small just because I am an individual, a mother, and not a big corporation. My phone calls & emails were returned promptly. They listened to exactly what I wanted & delivered. The defendant was nasty and ignored us and at times I felt like this was going nowhere. The attorneys worked well to reach a settlement that exceeded my expectations. Mr. Lieberman is a very seasoned lawyer who has compassion for his clients. The best thing about Mr. Lieberman is that he trains his staff to have that same level of compassion and respect for clients. " - Z.B., Jersey City, NJ

  • "I would like to personally thank Lieberman & Blecher for their help and advice to my family in dealing with an environmental cleanup issue. When it is a big company and their legal team against a small property owner, I have learned that you need an expert to protect your property and your rights. The team at Lieberman & Blecher did this for my family in a professional and cost effective manner. I would certainly recommend this firm to anyone in need of legal assistance" - C.K., Woodbridge, NJ

Contact The Toxic Injury Lawyers

Quick Contact Form